Items marked with * incur extra charges which are payable locally.
Reviews
Tripadvisor Traveller RatingBased on 13236 Reviews
Traveller ReviewsRanked #486 of 566 hotels in New York City
Traveller Rating
Excellent
5197
Very Good
2749
Average
2088
Poor
1260
Terrible
1942
Rating Summary
Location
Sleep Quality
Rooms
Service
Value
Cleanliness
9102 said...
A night to Remember. Service Excellence at all levels
Travelled on 11/2024
We decided to celebrate Thanksgiving in the Whistledown Hotel as my husband is a native of the US. We also wanted the evening to be an authentic North American Thanksgiving meal. We informed the Whistledown of our expectations - including succotash! About 30 people were invited for the full meal. The Whistledown excelled. It was truly spectacular from the decor in the room and the table layout -all with the U...
Read more
kelliemariel2020 said...
The best location and amazing staff average dated hotel but price reflects that
Travelled on 01/2025
On arrival I was tired and asked to leave s deposit of 228 dollars which I was told would be just held on my account. I was travelling with a 3 year old and luggage. The staff seemed friendly opened the doors so I could get the stroller in etc when I got to the floor it did look like a horror film it's really outdated and shabby. I'm not a hotel snob and it's one of the cheapest hotels in Manhattan I continued to the...
Read more
James P said...
Terrible hotel
Travelled on 01/2025
DONT BOOK THIS HOTEL !!
this is the worst hotel iv ever stayed in in my life absolutely dirty and the decor is from the 1950s..the rooms are freezing as the heaters don't work properly me & my partner were wearing thermals to bed under our pjs..hair stuck to the walls in the bathroom ...when we checked out we came to collect our bags later on in the day asked if there was somewhere were we could change to so we cou...
Read more
Leah W said...
Do not book this hotel!
Travelled on 01/2025
Do not book this hotel! Stayed here for 3 nights in jan 25 breakfast included! When we went down to look for the restaurant for breakfast there was no restaurant the breakfast was put into a paper bag in the lobby which was a croissant a peice fruit and 1 small coffee in a paper bag! We didnt bother we went out for breakfast. The rooms a very out dated and the walls of our bathroom was full of hair stuck to them it ...
Read more
Joy S said...
Will never stay again
Travelled on 01/2025
The staff was not friendly. They made you think they were giving you a special deal from them just for you when they were handing out free breakfast to everyone. Valets were forceful to take your luggage and tip. One floor had no hot water and they were not moving people. Awful experience....